Old Fashioned Ice Cream

Edit Content

The Menu

Fresh Ingredients. Real Flavors.

Over 50 Flavors!

Apple Pie

What’s more American than apple pie and ice cream? That’s why we merged the two together. We combine a freshly baked apple pie with our diary mix, to give you a taste of delight in every scoop.


Banana Pudding

Just like grandma’s banana pudding. We use real bananas and nilla wafers cookies.

Candy Bar Flavors (Butterfinger, Milky Way and Snickers)

We use a pound of your favorite frozen candy bars and crush them down into a powder. The powder is mixed with our dairy mix, so that every spoonful is filled with flavor.

Cotton Candy

The taste of cotton candy in homemade ice cream.

Fruit Based

Blueberry, watermelon, blackberry, orange pineapple. All of our fruit based ice creams are made with real fresh fruit. We try to use locally sourced ingredients whenever possible.

Key Lime

Our Key Lime is made with Nellie and Joe’s famous key west lime Juice.

Maple Walnut

Real maple syrup, caramel, chocolate syrup and wet walnuts are a few used in making this delicious ice cream.

Old Tyme Chocolate

We use Ghirardelli Chocolate with our diary mix to create a smooth tasting chocolate ice cream.

Peach Cobbler

Nothing tastes better than a peach cobbler with vanilla ice cream on top. That’s what we created, we mixed a real peach cobbler with our diary mix. You get the cobbler crust and the caramelized peaches throughout the ice cream. This is a customer favorite.


You will think you are eating a Reese’s peanut butter cup. Made with Reese’s Pieces.

Strawberry Cheesecake

2 pounds of whole strawberries go into each batch, along with a graham cracker crust.

Totally Coconut

A coconut lover’s dream, made with coconut milk and coconut flakes.


We use locally sourced honey to sweeten our vanilla ice cream. Locally-produced honey may help reduce seasonal allergy symptoms. Spring time in NC can be a challenge for those people with allergies, a scoop of our vanilla is refreshing from the heat but for allergies also.

Virgin Pina Colada

Made with crushed pineapple, coconut milk and coconut flakes.

Butter Finger
Banana Cream
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Milky Way
Coffee Cookie Chip
Raspberry Chip
Salted Caramel
Mint Chocolate
Orange Sherbet
Cookies & Brownies
Cinnamon Toast Crunch

Orange Pineapple
Rocky Road
Banana Pudding
Strawberry Cheesecake
Butter Pecan
Cotton Candy
Maple Walnut
Peach Cobbler
Pina Colada
Totally Coconut
Froot Loop
Caramel Apple
Cookie Dough

Pumpkin Walnut
Chocolate Fudge
Moose Tracks
Apple Pie
Cherry Cheesecake
Blackberry Cobbler
Lemon Pound Cake

Adult 21+

Bailey’s & Creme
Pina Colada
Long Island Iced Tea
White Russian
Rum Raisin
Honey Bourbon
Apple MoonShine
Screw Driver

Come Taste Old Fashioned Ice Cream


Monday – Wednesday: Closed

Thursday: 1pm – 6pm

Friday: 1pm – 8pm

Saturday: 12pm – 8pm

Sunday: 1pm – 8pm


124 N. Raiford St., Selma, NC

Follow us on social Media